The day the payout changed
On October 1, 2026, a lot of us found out that the way we get paid was about to look very different. Teachers Pay Teachers announced that it is replacing its Premium Seller membership with a new Exclusive Seller membership. Premium closed to new sign-ups right away, and current Premium Sellers keep their 80% rate through December 31, 2026.
Starting January 1, 2027, Exclusive Sellers earn a 77.5% payout rate and pay $59.95 a year, and in return they agree to sell their digital teaching resources only through TPT. Anyone who wants to keep offering those resources elsewhere can use the Basic Seller membership, which pays 55% on sales and charges a 30 cent transaction fee on every resource sold. The same day, Premium accounts move to Exclusive if the seller opted in, or to Basic if they did nothing.
TPT says it made the change because more and more of its resources are being sold on other sites, and that it wants a more unified marketplace. You can read TPT's reasons in its own words in the sources at the bottom of this page.
Why this one stings
Wardah makes resources too, and the seller groups have been on fire since that announcement. People are angry, and underneath it there's something heavier, which is the feeling of being stuck. Sellers put years into their stores, and now the people who built TPT are the ones paying for this.
Plenty of us spread our work across more than one shop for a sensible reason, since putting your whole income on one website feels a lot like building on rented land. Under the new rules, that careful choice has become the expensive one, because selling your digital teaching resources anywhere else means settling for 55% when the top rate is 77.5%. It feels a bit like being told you can keep your favorite stapler as long as you never staple anything outside the building.
What you do with an ultimatum
Under the new rules, the top payout depends on offering your digital teaching resources only through TPT, and putting them anywhere else means the Basic rate, which TPT says is unchanged. To us, that's an ultimatum, and when you get one, the right response is to walk away.
Doing it alone is risky, because a seller who moves to Basic gives up the top rate and still has to find buyers somewhere new. If 5,000 of us bring our resources to a marketplace sellers would own, and point our own email lists and Pinterest followers at the same place, it would give us a third choice, one where sellers vote on the payout rate.
So keep your TPT store as it is, and make your membership choice based on what's right for your store today. Then help us build somewhere worth walking to.
We kept thinking that if sellers make everything on the shelves, there has to be a way for them to own the shelves too.
The idea came from an airline, of all places
We borrowed the idea from @hitherehunter's Spirit Airlines video, so full credit goes to him. His math needed 50 million people, and by our rough math, ours needs 5,000, which feels very doable for a crowd that organizes field trips for a hundred kids without breaking a sweat.
If 5,000 sellers each pledged $25, that would be $125,000, which is our working estimate for building the marketplace. We still have to check that number against quotes from developers who've built this kind of site before, and we'll share what they tell us here, even if it's higher.
So where would the buyers come from?
Sellers who look at alternatives to TPT keep running into the same wall, and it's traffic. TPT has a built-in audience and years of search behind it, and a brand-new marketplace starts with neither.
Building the site is the easy part. Getting buyers there is the hard part, and it only works if we move together. One seller on a new site is a lonely little shop on an empty street, but when 5,000 sellers send their email lists and Pinterest followers to one place in the same week, it starts to look like a real marketplace.
We can't promise buyers or sales, and you should be wary of anyone who does. We'll post our plan for bringing buyers in here before the doors open, so everyone can pick it apart.
Owned by: us
If we pull this off, it's ours, and we mean actually ours. There would be no corporate boardroom deciding what your fraction worksheets are worth, and the only greed allowed would be fighting over the last donut in the teachers' lounge.
Under the proposal, sellers would own the marketplace together, with one vote each, whether your store has ten resources or ten thousand. Big decisions like the payout rate would belong to the people who make what's on the shelves, which is what a platform truly built by teachers, for teachers should look like.
Exactly who would count as an owner, and how someone would become one, still has to be settled with legal advice, so please treat all of this as a plan in progress that could change.
If you're skeptical, good
If you've watched other TPT alternatives pop up and rolled your eyes, that's fair, and this one deserves the same side-eye until it earns your trust. Every TPT figure on this site comes from TPT's own published pages, listed in the sources below, and you can check the payout math yourself.
So far, nobody has paid anything, and the pledge form doesn't even have a payment field. The $125,000 is a working estimate until real build quotes come in. Ownership and one seller, one vote are proposals that still need legal review, and this project isn't affiliated with or endorsed by TPT.
The fairest worry is that a new marketplace could start out friendly and rewrite the rules later, once someone else is calling the shots. That's the reason ownership sits at the center of this plan. Under the proposal, sellers would own it together with one vote each, so a change like the one TPT just made would need the sellers themselves to vote for it.
This will take time, and we'll do it properly
Setting up shared ownership the right way takes longer than putting up a website, and some steps will move slower than we'd like. If ownership is ever offered in exchange for money, that may count as a regulated offering, so we'll get legal advice and follow it before anyone could be asked for a cent. At every step, we'll tell you plainly what we know and what we're still figuring out.
What we're picturing
Imagine opening your seller dashboard on a marketplace you help own, where the payout rate was voted on by people who also spend their Sunday nights formatting PDFs. Imagine a buyer searching for a math unit and finding one made by a real teacher who knows exactly which part of equivalent fractions makes fourth graders groan.
That's the place we want to build, and it starts with a name. What would you call a marketplace built by teachers, for teachers? Send us your idea, and if you'd like to be counted, make a founding seller pledge.